Which Do You Like Least?


#1

UPDATE: Colored plates newly posted.
These are a selection of plates that will hold sushi like this:

for a card game I’m working on. I only need 12 plate styles, so just wanted to know which ones you guys liked the most versus the least? You can select multiples. I just want to get a feel for what you guys think even without the colors on these designs.



#2

I like them all but 13, 10, 12, and 5.


#3

Number 13. From a development standpoint it’s too generic and feels out of place with the others. The others at least look like they belong together, 13 just stands out as the generic plate/platter.


#4

I would say go for the obvious and cut out the most bland one.
If you only need 12 out of 13, I’d say don’t do 5 or 13.

Although I really like your drawing style, I’m not sure I understand what 10 is generally supposed to look like. Do you have a picture to compare it to?


#5

Ditch 5 and 13. :slight_smile:


#6

5 and 13 seem to generic to me (just like everyone else is saying). All the others seem to fit the bill for me, though 9 has me slightly confused. Is it a bowl? If so, bowls don’t seem like a good “plate” to put sushi on/in.


#7

Erase 13 and 5, maybe 7 from existence and it will be all good.


#8

13 is kind of boring, but the rest look good.


#9

I agree with most people, 13 I like the least


#10

I actually do not like 4 but think the rest are great!

5, 12 and 13 help break it up so that they aren’t all so wild looking.

Also, this little guy is too cute!


#11

10 is kinda my take on a sushi boat:

But I could tweak it so it looks more like it can support sushi, not have “seats” sorta.

So 5 and 13 seem to be the least liked. Thanks everyone! It gives me some new thoughts. I know 13 was pretty plain and I debated myself on how to color it to be more interesting…so I will drop 13, and with 5 I will make that one more colorfully interesting.


#12

You’re correct…I plan to use the bowl design for the tempura which will be sorta “jumping” around it. If it wasn’t well liked though, I’d have gone with a new idea.


#13

Ooo, that could look pretty cool then! I have never seen sushi presented in a bowl so I wasn’t sure what you were going for there. Best of luck!


#14

13 is boring.
I think you should unfill the panda in 7, like just have the outlines. 7 looks out of place because it’s the only one with a filled in object. After that I’d get rid of 9 and 2 because they are too complicated compared to the others.


#15

What? You no like panda? Actually I do know what you’re saying and that is a concern. The cards will be half the size of a poker card when done so detail limiting is something of a factor. The designs on 7 and 9 may have to go if they are too much for the scale.


#16

Not a fan of 6 or 13.


#17

5 and 13, the rest are great.


#18

Absolutely love 7. Don’t particularly dislike any, aside from the obvious 13.


#19

I :heart: : 1, 2, 5, 9, 10, 12, & 13

very cool Sledge!


#20

3, 8, 13 stand out for me.