I’m thinking in tier 1, the monster benefits from high burst damage, the ability to hardfocus a hunter down and his jumping traversal. The hunters counter this perfevtly with tranqs, harpoons, shielding on demand, and strong one person healing. Goliaths only advantahe is that flame breath does wonders against deployables. Hunters win though.
Tier 1.5 is the same in the opposite way. The monster is designed to spread out damage, so in comes a medic who can constantly spread out her healing and a support who can spread out shields. Hunters probably win again.
Tier 2 has what it takes to kill kraken. A good laz is a devent counter to kraken while bucket has decent weaponry against it, the harpoon gun works well enough and hydes no pushover, buuuut kraken is too good, since a good kraken is also a great counter to laz and can stay out of flame range. Maybe if they had stasis. Monster wins.
Tier 3 could melt wraith very fast if they are skilled. Cabot+parnell are just scary, buuut they are also tough to use. Parnell isnt gonna do anything if wraiths focusing him or skywraithing, and I feel like stasis doesnt work as well against wraith as other ccs. If they are on equal skill levels then Im goving it to wraith.
Tier 4 is behemoths end. They have the perfect kits to exploit his size, speed, lack of an aerial ability, melee focus etc. Mortars + jetpack booster + armor piercing rifle + spores is death. Hunters take it with 0 strikes.
Tier 5 is a bit more odd, Lenox doesnt do as well against gorgon as other assaults, but Emet and Kala really make it hard for it to focus on one spot, Jack also does pretty well I think (I’ve seen the least of this tier, so I may be uninformed). I’m thinking they take it in a long-ish match. Hunters win